Many critics and avid fans claim that the film industry has fallen off its high pedestal built with years of quality. But is this assumption actually true? Contrasting the films of the present with the ones of the past is one way to figure out if one is better than the other.
Feature films have always been culturally relevant ever since their inception in the early 1900s. The narratives of films started off simple. Comedies, dramas, and prewritten plays were the most popular forms of film at the time. The films being produced at the time were heavily constrained mainly by two factors: no audio tracks and no colour cameras. Yet, critically acclaimed motion pictures were made. Films that were praised then and are being praised now. Films that are definitively timeless. Examples commonly cited are “12 Angry Men”, “Citizen Kane”, and “Gone with the Wind”. All of these movies are from the first half of the 1900s. Most critics would consider these some of the greatest movies in history. These movies were well into the mainstream, each producing fairly large multiples of its budget as revenue.
To compare, some of the current highest grossing films are “Avatar”, “Avengers: Endgame”, and “Inside Out 2”. While none of these movies are considered terrible, most critics would consider these “sub-par”, especially considering how much money they’ve made. It seems as though the reception of mainstream movies has turned more or less sour in recent years.
A fitting explanation usually given is the survivorship bias associated with cherry-picking well-received mainstream films over the course of a hundred years and having to compare that to the films picked out over a decade or two in the present. Another simple reason could be the fact that most of the people who complain about modern movies being worse than older ones are driven by nostalgia, considering those movies made during their childhood to be definitive of what movies should entirely be.
On the other extreme, some people do genuinely consider all of modern cinema to have gotten much worse. Either due to oversaturation or the commercialisation of film.
The actual reason is probably more nuanced than it seems. The general public often acts as a monolith. The average person couldn’t care less about how passionately a film is made. The internet has allowed more people to osmose with each other. Causing a more monotonous view of the world held by an even bigger majority of the world than before the internet. This leads to simpler and safer movies taking a bigger slice of the box-office pie. The internet is definitely not entirely to blame, though. The internet has also created niche subcultures and an easier way for culturally alternative people to socialise. This leads to a surge of creativity and experimentation. A larger reason comes with commercialisation and greed.
While one singular company cannot be blamed for having taken advantage of being safe and simple with their movies, there is one extreme outlier. If you go through the thirty highest-grossing movies of the past 21st century, a whopping seventeen of them are from Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures. Of those seventeen, eight are part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, two are part of the Star Wars universe, three are sequels of original movies, one is a live-action remake of an original movie, and there are only two original movies.
Disney is considered the main culprit of having started the practice of “franchising”. The two largest assets they own are Marvel Studios and the Star Wars franchise. Marvel has two feature-length films and three shows scheduled for release this year, and Star Wars has one feature-length film and three shows scheduled for release this year.
All these films build upon themselves, which can be done right; however, Disney movies tend to be creatively bankrupt and rely far too much on the preceding films to help carry the box-office earnings. The same goes for companies like Universal Studios and Warner Brothers. A majority of their budgets are spent creating boring sequels and remakes.
This corporate and bureaucratic method of making films seems to be dragging down the reputation modern films have. While it is true that mainstream films are more commercial and accessible now, causing them to be more boring and less well-received by critics than older movies, there is no drought of creative, original and well-executed films in the independent space.
Outlets like MUBI exclusively publish arthouse, documentary and independent films. Having launchpads like MUBI built into the filmmaking process incentivises creative directors and writers to make films even if they are financially constrained. This is why we see films like “Obsession”, “The Blair Witch Project”, and “Paranormal Activity” be both critically acclaimed and still be popular. Films like the ones mentioned here are unfortunately not a common occurrence. Films like these will always stay a rare occurrence simply due to the fact that big commercial blockbusters suck up all the attention of a layman.
In conclusion, the conversation of whether older movies are better than modern movies is more grey than an extreme black or white. Film as a whole is definitely not any worse than it used to be. But an argument can be made whether mainstream film is worse than it used to be. In the end, just watch what you like. Spend the time and energy to look for something you’d like. It’s all subjective anyway.

Leave a Reply